PST
pacific standard time

Root
digitalmediatree

My Stuff
Current Page of PST
Daily Kos Diary
Trailers of Mass Desctruction
.......... Trailers of Mass Destruction -- old page
War of Words with Syria
water craft -- a paddling blog


PowerPoints of Terror
.......... Meet the War President
.......... Presidential Radio Address
.......... The Bush Doctrine Part II
.......... Union, State of
.......... Balloon Core of Death
.......... Vans of Mass Destruction
.......... Balloons of Mass Destruction
.......... Balloon Terror Alert System
.......... Nexus of Mass Destruction

Bumpersticker Gallery -- over 100!
.......... Bush 1984 + 19

Dr. Paul's Words of Wisdom
.......... a sampling of highlights
.......... Sea of Oil IISS, Guardian, etc.
.......... Bureaucracy Vanity Fair
.......... Democracy
.......... Politics
.......... all the instruments of national power
.......... money for warfighting Aug 2001???
.......... Lithuania Scenario

NYC 9/2000 photo essay
one lap archive

Sound track
west: your source for sound
south: the sound of NOLA
east: freeform radio

Political Blogs and/or Funnypages
All Hat No Cattle
alicublog
Alt Hippo
Bartcop
Bartcop E!
Big, Left, Outside
Body and Soul
Busy, Busy, Busy
California Insider
The Commons
Creek Running North
Crooks and Liars
Cursor
The Daily Howler
Daily KOS
Scooby Davis
DC Media Girl
Eschaton
Fanatical Apathy
the felonious elephant
feministe
firedoglake
Get Your War On
The Goddess
the girl gets away
Grand Moff Texan's Moment of Triumph
Hairy Fish Nuts
Harry Shearer
Happy Furry Puppy Story Time with Norbizness
Hullabaloo
Insomnia
Jesus' General
Make Them Accountable
Margaret Cho
MaxSpeak
McSweeney's
mikhaela
Obsidian Wings
Opinions You Should Have
Orcinus
O'Reilly Sucks
Pandagon
Pharyngula
Political Animal
Political Velocity
August J. Pollack
The Poor Man
Propaganda Remix Project
Pro-War.com
Sadly, No!
Superhappyfun Blog!!!
TBogg
Ted Rall
The Road to Surfdom
Rough & Tumble
Rubber Nun
Slacktivist
South Knox Bubba
Talking Points Memo
TBH Politoon
This Modern World
thoughtcrimes.org
uggabugga
Uncle Ernie's Issues and Alibis
Very Very Happy
War and Piece
What She Said
Whiskey Bar
Whiskey Fire
Wizard of Whimsy
World O'Crap

Archives
The Memory Hole
Billmon's Iraqi WMD Quotations
Billmon's Iraqi Democracy Quotations
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace -- Intelligence on Iraq
Where Are They(tm)
Center for Cooperative Research 9/11 Timeline
US-Iraq Timeline







View current page
...more recent posts

Friday, Mar 24, 2006

Home-schooled Ben Feels the Science at Us

Young Ben Domenech, a Republican operative, has landed a blogging position with the Washington Post. Lefty bloggers have been marking this event by mining Ben's personal blog for its rich veins of idiocy.

Although Pharyngula and The Supreme Irony of Life have already mined this post about the value of home schooling, there's enough residual idiocy for another pass.

I personally don't have a problem with evolution being taught in public schools. I occasionally have a problem with the way it is taught - as a final, solid, unquestioned truth, as opposed to a still-changing theoretical approach that many scientists think best explains the way things came to be.

Yglesias speaks about Darwinistic evolution as if it was a solid, undebatable fact, like 2+2=4. But the whole thing's a lot more complicated than that. An academic survey a couple of years ago found that nearly a third of hard scientists believed in theories other than the typical evolutionary construct - either something involving genetic mutation, or intelligent design, or something inspired by Stephen Jay Gould, or the like.
Let's start with the "solid, undebatable fact ... 2+2=4". Yeah, sure, that's totally "solid", as long as you've never heard of finite fields. But before we get to that, I'd like to congratulate young Ben for mastering elementary arithmetic, and would like to offer him the Richard Cohen Certificate of Achievement in First Grade Mathematics.

While elementary arithmetic is a fine skill, the whole thing's a lot more complicated than that. Any mathematician and those engineers steeped in coding theory are familiar with the concept of finite fields, also known as Galois fields, and can easily explain why in GF(3), 2+2=1. (Duh!)

While I was lucky enough to be introduced to the concepts of rings and fields in the 9th grade, perhaps they are too arcane. How about another topic, boolean algegra? This is a fundamental tool for each of the hundreds of digital hardware and software engineers who developed the various components of the machine at your very finger tips. Hundreds of thousands of engineers across the globe are quite familiar with the boolean equality 1+1=1, which equality would, like, totally blow young Ben's mind.

Perhaps we can glean a generalized moral, or a rule-of-thumb from this object lesson.
Try to avoid speaking authoritatively on a subject about which you have only the most rudimentary knowledge, lest you embarrass yourself by looking like an idiot.
With that moral in mind, let's turn to the biology portion of young Ben's post. Ben claims that "an academic report" found some "scientists believed in theories other than the typical evolutionary construct ... something involving genetic mutation". Hmmm, something involving genetic mutation, like, oh, I don't know, could it be EVOLUTION?!! The moral already needs some fine tuning, for young Ben lacks an understanding of even the rudiments of evolution, yet is compelled to excrete words on the topic. Genetic variation, arising from causes that include sexual reproduction and genetic mutation, is one of the pillars of evolutionary theory. That variation provides the inputs to the process of natural selection. Selection among identical clones doesn't result in evolution.

Young Ben offers the alternative of "something inspired by Stephen Jay Gould". Hmmm, could he mean Stephen Jay Gould the outspoken proponent of evolutionary theory? Perhaps Ben is confused by the notion that Gould's advocacy of punctuated equilibrium is inconsistent with Darwin's work. Richard Dawkin's dismantled that mistaken idea quite effectively in chapter 9 of The Blind Watchmaker ... some twenty years ago. Rather than being completely clueless, perhaps Ben is just slow on the uptake. Very slow.

It is discouraging that the Washington Post has given a pundit post to a young man who so clearly fails to understand his own limitations. But hey, the American people elected someone with a similar character flaw to the highest office in the land. Perhaps we're entering a new Era of Inadequacy, with people like young Ben at the vanguard.


- mark 3-24-2006 4:22 pm [link] [1 ref] [add a comment]