PST
pacific standard time

Root
digitalmediatree

My Stuff
Current Page of PST
Daily Kos Diary
Trailers of Mass Desctruction
.......... Trailers of Mass Destruction -- old page
War of Words with Syria
water craft -- a paddling blog


PowerPoints of Terror
.......... Meet the War President
.......... Presidential Radio Address
.......... The Bush Doctrine Part II
.......... Union, State of
.......... Balloon Core of Death
.......... Vans of Mass Destruction
.......... Balloons of Mass Destruction
.......... Balloon Terror Alert System
.......... Nexus of Mass Destruction

Bumpersticker Gallery -- over 100!
.......... Bush 1984 + 19

Dr. Paul's Words of Wisdom
.......... a sampling of highlights
.......... Sea of Oil IISS, Guardian, etc.
.......... Bureaucracy Vanity Fair
.......... Democracy
.......... Politics
.......... all the instruments of national power
.......... money for warfighting Aug 2001???
.......... Lithuania Scenario

NYC 9/2000 photo essay
one lap archive

Sound track
west: your source for sound
south: the sound of NOLA
east: freeform radio

Political Blogs and/or Funnypages
All Hat No Cattle
alicublog
Alt Hippo
Bartcop
Bartcop E!
Big, Left, Outside
Body and Soul
Busy, Busy, Busy
California Insider
The Commons
Creek Running North
Crooks and Liars
Cursor
The Daily Howler
Daily KOS
Scooby Davis
DC Media Girl
Eschaton
Fanatical Apathy
the felonious elephant
feministe
firedoglake
Get Your War On
The Goddess
the girl gets away
Grand Moff Texan's Moment of Triumph
Hairy Fish Nuts
Harry Shearer
Happy Furry Puppy Story Time with Norbizness
Hullabaloo
Insomnia
Jesus' General
Make Them Accountable
Margaret Cho
MaxSpeak
McSweeney's
mikhaela
Obsidian Wings
Opinions You Should Have
Orcinus
O'Reilly Sucks
Pandagon
Pharyngula
Political Animal
Political Velocity
August J. Pollack
The Poor Man
Propaganda Remix Project
Pro-War.com
Sadly, No!
Superhappyfun Blog!!!
TBogg
Ted Rall
The Road to Surfdom
Rough & Tumble
Rubber Nun
Slacktivist
South Knox Bubba
Talking Points Memo
TBH Politoon
This Modern World
thoughtcrimes.org
uggabugga
Uncle Ernie's Issues and Alibis
Very Very Happy
War and Piece
What She Said
Whiskey Bar
Whiskey Fire
Wizard of Whimsy
World O'Crap

Archives
The Memory Hole
Billmon's Iraqi WMD Quotations
Billmon's Iraqi Democracy Quotations
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace -- Intelligence on Iraq
Where Are They(tm)
Center for Cooperative Research 9/11 Timeline
US-Iraq Timeline







View current page
...more recent posts

Thursday, Apr 26, 2007

The Corps is Spinning the Pumps

The Army Corps of Engineers has published an article to explain the status of the pumps at the the outlets of the outfall canals.

(The breach of floodwalls on the 17th Street Canal and London Street Canal, "outfall canals", allowed water from Lake Ponchartrain to flood New Orleans. The major suburb of Metairie is also at risk if the west wall of the 17th Street Canal breaches. New Orleans was also flooded by breaches in the Industrial Canal, which is not being fitted with protective gates and associated pumps.)

This is the explanation for why they are publishing their version of the story:

Lately, there has been inaccurate and misleading reporting by local and national media about the history, status, and capabilities of the temporary pumps. In its continuing effort to remain open and transparent, the Corps offers accurate information regarding these vital elements of the Hurricane and Storm Damage Reduction System.
Here are some key paragraphs from the AP story they're complaining about.
The memo was written by Maria Garzino, a Corps mechanical engineer overseeing quality assurance at an MWI test site in Florida. The Corps confirmed the authenticity of the 72-page memo, which details many of the mechanical problems and criticizes the testing procedures used.

In her memo, Garzino told corps officials that the equipment being installed was defective. She warned that the pumps would break down ``should they be tasked to run, under normal use, as would be required in the event of a hurricane.''

The pumps failed less-strenuous testing than the original contract called for, according to the memo. Originally, each of the 34 pumps was to be ``load tested'' _ made to pump water _ but that requirement for all the pumps was dropped, the memo said.

Of eight pumps that were load tested, one was turned on for a few minutes and another was run at one-third of operating pressure, the memo said. Three of the other load-tested pumps ``experienced catastrophic failure,'' Garzino wrote.
Inadequate testing. Three out of eight tested units experienced catastrophic failure. Seems pretty clear.

In their article, the Corps doesn't refute the claims in the memo cited by AP, but merely makes excuses for why this was the best they could do under the circumstances. The Corps claims of "Inaccurate and misleading reporting" are arguments that aren't supported anywhere in their story.

The Corps claim of "its continuing effort to remain open and transparent" doesn't hold water either. If they are so open, why are they criticized for "checking their own work" in this Time-Picayune article.
[Walter] Baumy [chief engineer of the corps' New Orleans district.] said the document will include 170 or so plates detailing assumptions, methodologies, and data behind multiple seepage, pump and soils tests performed on all reaches of the canal, but it won't be handed off to local elected officials until specialists in the corps' Rock Island district and at corps division headquarters in Vicksburg, Miss., finish reviewing the work.

And that, in and of itself, is a big problem, said [Dr. Robert] Bea, a member of the Independent Levee Investigation Team financed by the National Science Foundation to study failures in the region's hurricane protection system.

The corps is reviewing its own work when experts independent of the agency should scrutinize it instead, said Bea, a former chief engineer for Shell Oil in New Orleans who began his career with the corps.

Bea and his colleagues, along with members of the state-fielded Team Louisiana investigators, have said the corps must open itself to true outside collaboration and review -- not just talk about doing so.

"When are these guys going to learn? This is like running into the gang of bullies who beat you up yesterday and having them say, 'Trust us today,' " Bea said. "Nineteen months after Katrina, they're still checking their own work. They should be inviting peer review and welcoming collaboration as a way of showing that they really want to move forward together."
I'm not buying the Corps line that they are misunderstood. They are underperforming, and don't like being called on it.

- mark 4-26-2007 11:16 pm [link] [add a comment]

Blame the Victim

Under the Patriot Act, Iraqi victims of kidnappings are sometimes seen as providing "material support" of terrorists, and won't be allowed to immigrate to the U.S.

The hairdresser is a single mother. She received threats by phone and in writing. She was told to close her salon, judged as unacceptable by Muslim extremists. In 2005, a man in a black hood entered her shop, beat her, pulled the crucifix off her neck and raped her. A week later, her son was kidnapped and the same man called; she recognized his voice. He demanded $10,000. She gathered $7,000 and paid the ransom. Her son was returned, and she fled the country with him.

At issue here is whether the rapist/kidnapper is a member of a U.S. government-documented terrorist group. Even ransom can constitute "material support" of terrorists. But if money is given "under duress" to a group that is not on either of the two State Department lists of foreign terrorist groups, the "material support" restriction can be waived.

Mercury News

- mark 4-26-2007 10:14 pm [link] [add a comment]

Chickenhawk Salad on Wonderbread, with a side of Cheetos

When the troops are withdrawn from Iraq, the wingnuts will blame this fiasco on the people who said it was going to be a fiasco in the first place. And they will blame it on people caught up in George's folly. We've already seen examples of wingnuts blaming the Iraqi people. Here's a wingnut on the Cheetos-stained Vanguard, ready, willing and able to place blame on the troops and their families.

"We're Tired....Waugh, Waugh, Waugh!"

I just heard a leftist who claimed to be the wife of a U.S. soldier serving in Iraq on C-SPAN. I doubt that she was really connected to any service-member...but...

She said, "We're tired."

[Snip]

Our troops are tired of war...it's only natural. Our people are tired of the war as well. But that does not mean we should just lay down and hand murderous islamist thugs a victory.

- mark 4-26-2007 6:09 pm [link] [5 comments]

older posts...